What would your average rating be? Partagas Serie P Number 2

[El Presidente]

I am going to run this poll series over the course of this week before pooling and analysing the result.

If these cigars are in your rotation, please take part. Let's define rotation as  a cigar that is smoked at least once every four  months 

In terms of ratings, live with the points system as put forward. Some members use stars, others have a 10 point assessment process, others use bananas.......it doesn't really matter....just adapt as best you can. 

Partagas Serie P Number 2 

 

[JV0505]

They’re awesome hardy sticks!

[Chas.Alpha]

@Elpresidente are you thinking of my Christmas gift? 😬

[Shakey]

I know this is sacrilege but...I prefer the Monte 2.  

[Chibearsv]

15 minutes ago, Shakey said:

I know this is sacrilege but... I prefer the Monte 2.  

I don’t know how that’s sacrilege. Monte 2 can be a hell of a cigar. P2 is a consistent rich regular for me. 91-92 almost always. 

[Boxer31]

One from the summer was 98+. My cigar of the year. 

[BG318]

Love the vitola. Love the brand. No surprises that I enjoy this cigar. I couldn't choose between a Diplo 2, M2, Upmann 2, or a P2 on any given day. It would depend on my mood at the moment of selection.

[gormag38]

19 hours ago, Shakey said:

I know this is sacrilege but...I prefer the Monte 2.  

Hey you like what you like my guy! For me the M2 has always been a little too forward (at least when young). The good/great ones I've had always have some years on 'em, I find it brings some of the cream into play which I'm typically all about. 

The P2 on the other hand has been one of the most consistent cigars for me the last couple years. I blew through a MTS 21 box and picked up a UBL 23 box earlier this year. So far the new ones have been a notch below the 21s but still a sub 90 cigar every time.