In the last 3 years, what are your 6 favorite regular production Cuban Cigars?

[SMELTZ]

Cigars are great when by yourself, but when with friends they are even better.  Something about a group of friends and smoking cigars is a blissful moment.  What regular production cigars have you enjoyed the most over the last three years either by yourself or with friends?  List your six favorite regular production cigars from 2019 to present. 

 

1. Cohiba Piramides Extra

2. H. Upmann Sir Winston

3. Cohiba Esplendido

4. Partagas Lusitanias

5. Bolivar Libertador

6. Punch Punch

[Edicion]

This is a good but common topic. Here's a good resource

https://www.fohcigars.com/forum/forum/115-foh-deep-dives/

And there's another thread which lists the highest ranked ones at the moment.

13 minutes ago, SMELTZ said:

4. Partagas Double Corona

5. Ramon Allones Libertador

I presume you mean Partagas Lusitania and Bolivar Libertador.

Many good cigars in your list and never had a bad Cohiba Piramides 

[Chas.Alpha]

54 minutes ago, SMELTZ said:

Cigars are great when by yourself, but when with friends they are even better.  Something about a group of friends and smoking cigars is a blissful moment.  What regular production cigars have you enjoyed the most over the last three years either by yourself or with friends?  List your six favorite regular production cigars from 2019 to present. 

 

1. Cohiba Piramides Extra

2. H. Upmann Sir Winston

3. Cohiba Esplendido

4. Partagas Double Corona

5. Ramon Allones Libertador

6. Punch Punch

Now a list for the common piker:

Boli Royal Corona

Monte #1

Boli PC

Partagas P2

Partagas Short

Upmann #2

🤔

[LizardGizmo]

1. Partagas 8-9-8
2. H. Upmann Sir Winston
3. Montecristo #2
4. Partagas Lusi
5. QD Coronas Claros
6. RASS

[williamthewolf]

Enjoyed both alone and with friends.

1. Diplomaticos 2

2. Monte PE

3. Partagas D4

4. RyJ Short Churchill

5. Partagas D5

6. Juan Lopez 1

[Tstew75]

Faves with zero regard for price:

• JL1
• Monte Esp2
• Monte Dumas/Maltes
• Cohiba Sig II (El Laguito)
• CPE
• Upmann Mag 46
• PSE2

 

 

[btort910]

in no particular order:

Dip 2

JL1

Connie A

Mag 46

Trinidad Vigia

VR Famosos

[Akela3rd]

Always worth chucking in your twopenneth on these little list threads. With no thought whatsoever this emerged and is therefore true at the moment:
Party Shorts
Bolivar PC
Dip2
RASS
RASCC
JL 1

And PSD4, Monte Edmundo for good measure. All RP, all good. Done.

Sent by spooky action at a distance

[joeypots]

In no particular order.

RASS

MCDE

MC#1

PP

Siglo IV

[Ford2112]

Random order:

Co.Ro

Rg Perlas

Party 898

Bolivar PC

E2

PLMC

[bmac]

Coro

La Fuerza

HDM2

Trinidad Vigia/Coloniales

JL2

E2

[Bijan]

1. Going by what I smoked most:

Hoyo du député : 37

monte 4: 16

RG perlas: 16

plmc: 15

Bolivar tubos no. 3: 15 (regular production though discontinued now)

Hoyo du maire: 15

(For reference I smoked 13 Siglo II and 10 Siglo III)

2. Going by what i enjoyed most (and was consistent):

(Number smoked for comparison with above)

Siglo IV: 7

Monte Especial: 4

Fundadores: 6

Hoyo Epi 1: 7

Partagas 8-9-8: 6

Monte 1: 8

(Siglo II would have bumped the epi 1 if prices hadn't gone crazy)

3. Edit: and if i had an unlimited supply and didn't have to care about cost, supply or consistency:

(Number smoked again for comparison with above)

Siglo V: 6

Sir Winston: 4

Cohiba lanceros: 3

Esplendidos: 5

Siglo III: 10

Piramides extra: 1

[Bill Hayes]

JL#2, Coro, Monte 2, Bolivar PC, Party short, RASS

[hrs1]

Siglo V

RAG

CoLa

Sir Winston

Esplendidos

Fundy

 

[SMELTZ]

Interesting…Partagas E2 getting lots of love. Never liked them until 2020 boxes

[fisherclive]

Montecristo Dumas 

Partagas E2

Cohiba Siglo II

Cohiba Robusto 

Partagas P2

Montecristo no.2

 

[Ford2112]

5 hours ago, SMELTZ said:

Interesting…Partagas E2 getting lots of love. Never liked them until 2020 boxes

They rock

[JohnS]

On 9/18/2022 at 6:23 AM, Bijan said:

1. Going by what I smoked most:

2. Going by what i enjoyed most (and was consistent):

3. Edit: and if i had an unlimited supply and didn't have to care about cost, supply or consistency:

Haha...can you do that for me in Cuban Cigar Website with my stats?

Of course, I'm just joking! 😂

[Bijan]

13 hours ago, JohnS said:

Haha...can you do that for me in Cuban Cigar Website with my stats?

Of course, I'm just joking! 😂

I did mine based on just manually searching and looking at the match count in the browser search bar.

But it would be really easy to find the count old school Unix text tools.

Just copy and paste into a file, use cut to select the vitola column. Use sort to sort alphabetically. Use uniq -c to count consecutive occurrences and sort -n to sort by these numbers.

The only complications are 1: to handle gifts.

2 to handle scores.

In your case I think you rate all cigars except trades and gifts. 

So that only leaves scores to deal with. I'll start with the vitola counts and do the scores later.

tl;dr I'm on it!

[Bijan]

13 hours ago, JohnS said:

Haha...can you do that for me in Cuban Cigar Website with my stats?

Of course, I'm just joking! 😂

Here's your top 10 (all time (2016 to present), quick shot):

    72                                 Montecristo Montecristo No.4
    66                                 San Cristóbal de la Habana El Príncipe
    58                                 Por Larrañaga Montecarlos (2)
    55                                 El Rey del Mundo Demi Tasse
    52                                 Small Cigars Cohiba Shorts
    44                                 Montecristo Montecristo No.2
    40                                 Rafael González Perlas
    39                                 Romeo y Julieta Churchills
    36                                 Hoyo de Monterrey Le Hoyo du Prince
    35                                 Montecristo Montecristo No.5

Top 10 (last 3 years, September 20th 2019 to present):

    40                                 Montecristo Montecristo No.4
    29                                 Montecristo Montecristo No.5
    23                                 Nudies N3 Carlota
    22                                 Nudies N1 Lancero
    20                                 H. Upmann Connoisseur No.1
    20                                 Hoyo de Monterrey Le Hoyo du Maire
    19                                 Quai d'Orsay No.50
    19                                 El Rey del Mundo Demi Tasse
    18                                 Por Larrañaga Montecarlos (2)
    17                                 San Cristóbal de la Habana El Príncipe

I'll try to do your top rated soon.
 

[JohnS]

2 minutes ago, Bijan said:

Here's your top 10 (all time (2016 to present), quick shot):

Top 10 (last 3 years, September 20th 2019 to present):

I'll try to do your top rated soon.

What can I say...genius! 👍

[Puros Y Vino]

Random order.

RyJ Cazadores. HUHC. PSD4. Sig II.  Connie A.

RyJ Churchill 

[Luca]

In no order:

- Montecristo No.4

- Qdo Corona

- Montecristo Edmundos 

- Montecristo Especiale

- ERDM Demi Tasse (mine have aged 5 years but I love them fresh aswell)

[Blakes]

BBF 

Bolivar Corona Junior

Ramon Allones Small Club Corona 

Hoyo Du Depute

Partagas Short

RyJ Petit Corona

 

 

[BrightonCorgi]

Cohiba Esplendido

Upmann Sir Winston

Cohiba Robusto

Monte Double Edmundos

Juan Lopez No. 2

Fonseca. No. 1