Recommended Posts

Posted

I am wondering what CC you find as the most inconsistent in quality and therefore deem risky to purchase. My RUM MAR 19 Monte #2s, like previous boxes, are frustratingly overfilled, ruining any potential smoking satisfaction. (On the flip side, to me, VR Famosos have always performed beautifully.)

Posted
Monte 2 is certainly up there. Siglo II would be for me as well.
Interesting.
The no.2 and Siglo II are 2 of my all time favorites and have smoked a lot of and never had any issues with either.

Must have good luck

Sent from my SM-G930V using Tapatalk

  • Like 2
Posted

I’ve been put off Bolivar after a bad box of Petit Coronas (ETP MAR 17) and an even worse box of Royal Coronas (PUS MAY 19). Neither box from here, by the way! Should probably give the marca another chance.

  • Like 1
Posted
11 hours ago, Vitola Corleone said:

R&J Churchills for me.

But I keep buying them because they're real good for me when they're on, I love the vitola, and can be found for decent prices. 

+1 here.  I love a well made RyJ Churchill but they certainly can have issues.

Posted

BRC is by far the most inconsistent performer over a decade plus for me.  I keep buying because I love good ones, but I’ve had more bad boxes of these than anything else.

  • Like 1
Posted

My experience has been that the Partagas SD#4 can be wildly inconsistent. 

  • Like 1
Posted
28 minutes ago, Lrabold89 said:

its funny when ppl make these statements like they never have issues...............i can say conservatively that i probably end up tossing  about 25% of my CCs due to poor/intolerable flavor, construction/draw/burn issues  ........and i do not have storage issues .......sometimes its literally like 2 or 3 in a row before i get a good one 

Hate to say it but this is kind of where I am right now, too. Seems like I have a 1 in 3 on base % for my most recent CCs living up to expectation from flavor, construction, and burn perspectives. However, I had a tremendous Mag 46 this past Friday that offsets the frustrations of having to weed thru the negative smokes. It is what it is...

Posted
4 hours ago, smbauerllc said:

The no.2 and Siglo II are 2 of my all time favorites and have smoked a lot of and never had any issues with either.

I buy a lot of Siglo II and since 2018 haven't had any issues - can't say the same for Monte 2. Qdo has not been very consistent for me either. I've also gotten a lot of plugged or near-plugged Reyes to the point where I've basically stopped buying them. 

Posted
29 minutes ago, Lrabold89 said:

i will say that one important factor is if ive had a box for at least a year it is more likely to perform better .......less than that...forget abotu it...all chance 

And I've found that once the cigars are 4 or 5 years of age the #s of duds decreases dramatically. I smoked a HURR from '12 a few weeks ago. First truly compromised  due to poor draw cigar I have smoked in a while. 

  • Like 2
Posted

I smoke 2/3 cc's and honestly don't really have a problem very often, and when I do its just a tight draw.

It mainly only happens with under 40rg sticks, which is part of why I don't buy many.

To be fair though, I don't buy boxes, so i have much fewer ones of the same marca and vitola at a time to compare like you would in boxes, and what singles, 3,4,and and 5 packs I but range in year of manufacture a lot, so likely another reason I have fewer problems.

Sent from my SM-G930V using Tapatalk

  • Like 2
Posted
I buy a lot of Siglo II and since 2018 haven't had any issues - can't say the same for Monte 2. Qdo has not been very consistent for me either. I've also gotten a lot of plugged or near-plugged Reyes to the point where I've basically stopped buying them. 
Yeah, all of my Siglo Ii's are 2019 or 2020 and have been very good in every regard for the most part.

Also buy a fair number of no.2's and cant recall having any issues with the same years.

Just had my first of 3 QDO 50's, so I can't say on those.

Loved it enough that if the next 2 are just as good, I may buy a box of 10, then we'll see if I have any problems

Sent from my SM-G930V using Tapatalk

Posted

This thread, if pinned to the top would likely contain every cigar in the catalogue. This means, there is but one answer. Cigars are a crapshoot.

In years past I looked for cigars from a more vast catalogue that represented only a small fraction of production. Without a shortage that plages a popular cigar, the lesser popular cigars would sit and not be pushed into production with marginal quantities/qualities of component parts. This net for me very high numbers of consistent cigars.

With many of the Coronas, PCs and Lonsdales gone due to (ostensible) lack of popularity, these 'uncommon' cigars are no long around. There only seems to remain 'popular' cigars and we are full circle. Shortages beget voids and runs on cigars, pushing the 'powers' to produce them will little care. Sometimes you get good ones, and sometimes you get crap. Tabacuba does not seem to be taking the crap back!

Regardless of these production issues, CC are bought anyway. If one need not make them better, why make them better? Pride??? I don't think so! If the consumer does not demand it, he/she won't get it...

-the Pig

  • Like 4
Posted

Better to ask what current production cigars your find to be more consistent instead. 

Posted
1 hour ago, PigFish said:

This thread, if pinned to the top would likely contain every cigar in the catalogue. 

:clap:

Posted
11 hours ago, Lrabold89 said:

its funny when ppl make these statements like they never have issues...............i can say conservatively that i probably end up tossing  about 25% of my CCs due to poor/intolerable flavor, construction/draw/burn issues  ........and i do not have storage issues .......sometimes its literally like 2 or 3 in a row before i get a good one 

Same. It makes me think I'm either picky or folks have a hard time admitting they got a crappy cigar in the Cuban Roulette. I'm not happy when I do, and before I realized how inconsistent they were I figured I must be missing something, but it seems like those who smoke CC and NC are more willing to be...sincere? with their criticism of both origins vs people who only smoke one or the other. 

  • Like 1
Posted
15 minutes ago, SmokyFontaine said:

Same. It makes me think I'm either picky or folks have a hard time admitting they got a crappy cigar in the Cuban Roulette. I'm not happy when I do, and before I realized how inconsistent they were I figured I must be missing something, but it seems like those who smoke CC and NC are more willing to be...sincere? with their criticism of both origins vs people who only smoke one or the other. 

Even in their inconsistency CCs are inconsistent. I had a box of Partagas Mille fleurs that was 2/3 plugged and most were a struggle to smoke even though I smoked the whole box.

Right now I'm smoking a Siglo III and this box hasn't been the best but still a million times better than that box of MF.

I tend to smoke the duds to the band if they are at all smoke able and not total tent pegs. Once or twice I stopped halfway on a cigar because the flavours were off, last time was a nudies n1. Anyways I think smoking the duds makes me appreciate the good ones more.

On that note @Habana MikeMike is sending me a big set of tent pegs from his collection. I hope to smoke all of those and document my experience for science 😂 We'll see if I can make it through that batch.

  • Like 1
Posted
Just now, mprach024 said:

This rumor again?

He sent me a picture of a bunch he picked out. I'm interested to see how this long con plays out :rotfl:

  • Haha 2
Posted

I have (had?) a box of Cosacos that were all plugged, or thought. I weighed them all, picked out the lightest ones and have smoked two. They weren’t plugged. So, I’ve been weighing mine lately to get an idea on plugged or wide open draws. Thought I had a process down until I pulled out 2 EPI #2’s last night. If I remember correctly, one was 10.9g and one was 10.4. I started with the 10.9g. Wide open draw. Though, crap, the other is going to be the same. Put the 10.9 back in the humidor to smoke later and at a higher Rh. Smoked the 10.4, perfect draw. I know we are talking tenths of a gram, and I guess that’s the point, the bunching may have a lot to do with it. And based on that, who knows what the box of Cosacos has in store. Now, those ranged from 7-9gs. 

  • Like 1

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

Community Software by Invision Power Services, Inc.