Punch 48 - Unknown date - (PQDRW)

[JGD]

This will be a very short review, because frankly the cigar didn’t give me much to say. The only way to describe it is by saying it was a dud. Now, it wasn’t necessarily bad, just wasn’t good. Absolutely no change (that I could pick up at least) in the flavors while smoking. The Who cigar was a stable barnyard and leather. But again, not necessarily the barnyard or leather that you seek out in s cigar. I’ll give this one a 2/5, only because it wasn’t bad enough to toss. I have another one in my cooler, so I may give it a try in the near future and hope for a different result. 

 

[rcarlson]

You're harshing my mellow.  I have a box of 10 on the way.  Hope it was just a dud.  

[Fatshotbud]

Bummer - the couple boxes I have smoked were consistently good. Hopefully you can have a better experience next time.
Think I am about 10 boxes and will probably add more.

Sent from my KYOCERA-E6560 using Tapatalk

[TheMonk]

Shame about your stick, but it does happen!

[rcarlson]

Alright, tried one after 30 days down.  Yuk!  Worst CC I've ever had.  Bitter and acrid wind tunnel.  I sure hope it too was a dud.  Was hoping for so much more.  Let me know how your next goes.  Maybe there'll be some reason for optimism.