Desert Island Cigars

[JohnInCleveland]

I'm aware that similar threads have existed, but I'm putting a little spin on this and hoping it sparks some interesting responses...

 

1.  You only get one brand to smoke for the rest of eternity.  You can have anything under that brand in perpetuity.  

 

2.  You only get one cigar to smoke for the rest of eternity.  Non regional editions, regular production cigar

 

3.  You only get one cigar to smoke for the rest of eternity, no restrictions, new or old, doesn't have to be readily avaliable.

[dvickery]

Dunhill varaderos

derrek

[SignalJoe]

If you can guarantee me good rosado wrapper; RyJ Churchill if not CoRo.  

[Fuzz]

HdM Des Dieux. Never get tired of it. Perfect size for me.

[JohnS]

I'll have what Fuzz is having!  

[Optic101]

With Fuzz an John. 

[Troels]

Upmann

mag 46/pc

[SirVantes]

Following OP's interesting criteria:

1. Cohiba (if allowed anything current and future under the brand) or RA (if also allowed anything historical under the brand).

2. LGC Mdo2 (or if that's not deemed current production, then Cohiba Lanceros).

3. RA Grandes. I plead the recency effect.

[Winchester21]

1 Cohiba

2 Coro or Siglo 4-Both of which I am nearly and completely out of now

3 Bolivar Gold Medal - the real ones not the LCDH( or whoever it was) reproduction

[losttrailer]

2 hours ago, Optic101 said:

With Fuzz an John. 

So we are four now :-)

[zeedubbya]

1.) Cohiba

2.) Siglo 2 (would go with larger cigar like Siglo 6 or Winnie but I don't think I would like being forced to fire up a cigar that large every day)

3.) Cohiba Gran Reserva (And I just contradicted #2, oh well, three or 4 puffs and toss on GR--so be it., assuming an unlimited supply.)

[canadianbeaver]

1. Cohiba 

2. RG Corona Extra 2009 or whatever*

*if not available, ERDM 2009

3. Ramon Allones EL 2015

CB

 

[Guest Nekhyludov]

1) Padron. Sorry, but performance and reliability matter - especially in perpetuity, forever.

2) HUSW

3) Cuban Davidoff No. 1

[BrightonCorgi]

1. Cohiba

2.  LGC No. 2

3.  Old Cohiba Lanceros?

[Duxnutz]

1. Tie Cohibar or Hoyo 

2. Coro

3. ERDM Lonsdale 

[planetary]

Not at all sure about single cigar yet.  Desert island brand, though, is Cohiba.  Hands down.

[noreaster]

Dantes 109..

[RijkdeGooier]

1. Montecristo

2. Laguito 1

3. Laguito 1 maybe Salomones II

[Laxman]

1) Partagas 

2)  D4

3) CGR

[cigcars]

      * I don't believe you disallowed discontinued regular productions - did you? And since everybody's taking the liberty of stating their three bests (preferences), for me:

      1) Ramon Allones 898 Cabinet (Varnished)

      2) Punch Black Prince

      3) Por Larranaga Magnums

        * Much thanks to Perelman's Pocket Cyclopedia of Havana Cigars, Third Edition!

[BuzzArd]

What's my guarantee that the sole vitola I choose will be spot-on stick after stick?  

[Ken Gargett]

1 hour ago, BuzzArd said:

What's my guarantee that the sole vitola I choose will be spot-on stick after stick?  

you can probably find it written into the same mythical document that condemns you to this island and provides you with an endless supply of cigars.

if the magic pudding of cigars exists, why would it give you duds?

[Fuzz]

26 minutes ago, Ken Gargett said:

you can probably find it written into the same mythical document that condemns you to this island and provides you with an endless supply of cigars.

if the magic pudding of cigars exists, why would it give you duds?

Because it is a fay and fickle puddin'.

[JohnInCleveland]

7 hours ago, cigcars said:

      * I don't believe you disallowed discontinued regular productions - did you? And since everybody's taking the liberty of stating their three bests (preferences), for me:

      1) Ramon Allones 898 Cabinet (Varnished)

      2) Punch Black Prince

      3) Por Larranaga Magnums

        * Much thanks to Perelman's Pocket Cyclopedia of Havana Cigars, Third Edition!

I spoke with the judges...

 

Our island will allow it.  

[Wertman]

Nice mix just had a bolivar libertadore and it was amazing.  I could see myself only smoking that cigar everyday especially if I had nothing but time