The Cigars you are not quite sure you like......"yet"

[topdiesel]

I can't beleive how many don't like Bolivar. I am not in that group.

I have tried several times and just don't want to give up on them:

Punch Punch

PL Montecarlos or Panatelas

[foursite12]

Monte 2. Maddening. I was just singing their praises a couple weeks ago and yes, many are praiseworthy. But too often I'll grab one that's completely boring. After an utterly non-descript episode in the cold yesterday, I have dropped them from my Piramide "Stick to Stock" category and re-opened the competition. Not awful; just too damned unreliable.

Mag 46. After a truly unfortunate first cigar, the remaining 24/25 of the box are now down deep to see if they can sleep it off. The most disappointing cigar of the year for me. I remain hopeful and fortunately there are so many really solid candidates in this vitola I can be patient. Will dust another one off in 6 months or so.

[ErikB]

Anything Cohiba

[Bartolomeo]

Monte DE

RASS.... Have had a few good ones but maybe not trying the "right ones"

Cohiba 1966....tasty upon release but nothing great since

JL #2.... Love the PC, love #1 but these have been meh for me

Cohiba Piramide.....Love Cohiba, love the size but no such luck for me.....or maybe this is just not a good cigar? Would love to have good luck w this cigar

Mag 46/50......Love Upmann but not these

[SurpriseMVP]

Picadores

But now leaning towards I like them

Mike

[Sigaar]

RASS. I've had 2 or 3, and all were meh. Still have a few resting...TBD.

[subport]

Ehm, that box of Cohiba Behike BHK 54. (BTO SEP 13)

Only smoked 3 out of the box, but never really outstanding or blown away. Not even close to it. Quite okay, kinda basic or standard. Expected more, lot more...

The OR 52 I liked so much but ...

[Guest RobB]

Cohiba Maduro 5 line.

I'm a maduro ***** and expected these to be up there with the best, they missed by a country mile IMO. Got some sitting to see how they transition with age.

[GasGuy82]

Ramon Allones Superiores. Everyone loves this cigar, I want to like it but just am let down every time I have one. Have some fear that the box will turn down the road and I will be left having not stocked up ala people today regarding BGMs.

3 cigars I keep trying but can't seem to develop any love for are PSD4, Monte No.2 and JL#4

[CdnLimitada]

Like many, Bolivar. I would also add most Partagas. I think it is the strength more than anything.

Love the Gold Medals but that is about it for Bolivars that I have tried. Lustis are real good most of the time. Shorts are okay.

[JC67]

Cohibas for me, I have never had one that justifies its position

[smokeyjoe01]

Got some El Principe, waiting patiently trying one every few months hoping they'll get in their zone

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[westg]

Partagas 898 have a box from 2011 and smoked one of Jokers on Saturday....I can pick that cigar from all others ...why because I don't know if I really like it ...those paprika Capsicum type flavours really stand out to me... guess I'm just a Monte fiendish

[Shrody234]

Monte no2

Had one recently that was stellar. All the mocha notes it delivered hit the spot. Hoping the 10 count box will make me a convert.

[PHXCSC]

EL's in general with a few obvious exceptions

[leftimatic]

PSD4. Had a real bell ringer and been chasing dragons ever since.

[mygar]

PSD4 for me too... although it could have been my storage conditions at that time.

[squizz]

Monte Medio corona

Same here.

[stunod]

Partagas 898. Never outstanding but the 2 boxes I have are young, 2014. I will continue to try every so often to see.

[maxcjs0101]

I seem to not get much taste from Dominican cigars too. I would get heavy earth, leather and occasional spice but thats about it.

[Boosted]

RASS and PSD 4- I've smoked over a box of each and have never seen the appeal.

JL #2- I love JL #1, but do not care for the #2.

HDM Epi 2- Epi 1 is a staple in my humidor, but don't like Epi #2

Upmann #2- Upmann is what I own the most of, and it is probably my favorite brand. I've had several Upmann #2 from various years and a few LUB 14, but I just can't get behind them.

SLR Regios- I've tried 3 out of my box, and I think it's the most boring cigar I've ever had. I love SLR A and DC, but Regios I've smoked have been crap.

[maxcjs0101]

RASS and PSD 4- I've smoked over a box of each and have never seen the appeal.

JL #2- I love JL #1, but do not care for the #2.

HDM Epi 2- Epi 1 is a staple in my humidor, but don't like Epi #2

Upmann #2- Upmann is what I own the most of, and it is probably my favorite brand. I've had several Upmann #2 from various years and a few LUB 14, but I just can't get behind them.

SLR Regios- I've tried 3 out of my box, and I think it's the most boring cigar I've ever had. I love SLR A and DC, but Regios I've smoked have been crap.

You just dont like them Robustos?

[ErikB]

When they first came out I was crazy about Vegas Robainas, then had two bad boxes a couple of years ago which made me forget about them. But smoking a Famosos now and really loving it

[Ryan]

Monte Edmundo and Petit Edmundo. They've just never really "done it" for me.

I may have had a bitter one years ago that turned me off.

[Boosted]

You just dont like them Robustos?

No, I don't. I will always buy the corona gorda of the same marca if it is available. Me and Robustos just don't get along. I don't own a single box of robustos, but I do have a couple boxes of Hermoso 4.