Recommended Posts

Posted

I am sure we all do it lol3.gif

You read here and elsewhere of how a member "hates"....."can't stand" ..."has never had a good one" of this cigar or that.

"I have never ever had a great D4 (substitute CORO or BRC or anything)"

....you say to yourself.....YOU HAVE TO BE KIDDING! lol3.gif

We all have different tastes and that is a good thing!

However, what is that cigar that you consistently love that receives a bad rap and makes you say to yourself....You have to be kidding!

Posted

In all honesty, I rarely have a poor Monte 4. Some are better than others, but I have only had a handful of disappointing ones and I've had loads of them!

  • Like 1
Posted

How about the other way around. Everyone seems to rave about PL Montecarlos. (You have to be kidding!) I don't like them at all. I don't know what others see in them. But I love PLPC, Encantos and PL Panetelas. Go figure...

I have nothing to offer about what I like but others hate. Maybe QDO corona and MC #3 I guess. They don't seem to get too much love.

-Dan

  • Like 3
Posted

i've never had a bad PSD4. then again all my psd4s come from Rob...so i guess hes my good luck charm on my favorite cigar

  • Like 3
Posted

Monte #4. It still amazes me that so many knock this cigar down when I have had nothing but stellar examples from many boxes over the years. True I do get mine hand picked by either our gracious host on here or in Cuba so that may sway the odds in my favour of getting the cream of the crop.

  • Like 1
Posted

RyJ Short Churchill

Posted

Monte #4. It still amazes me that so many knock this cigar down when I have had nothing but stellar examples from many boxes over the years. True I do get mine hand picked by either our gracious host on here or in Cuba so that may sway the odds in my favour of getting the cream of the crop.

Monte4 is a great cigar. Working on a 2012 box now and they are fantastic flavor bombs.

Posted

Trinidad Reyes

Don't hear many good reports about the marca as a whole but 90% of the ones I've smoked over the years have been quite good

This is out of a sample size of about 24 different sticks. Different dates, different codes

  • Like 3
Posted

Love PSD4's and JL 2's. Seem to always find people that do not like either or claim to have never had a good one. I boxes of both from at least 07 to present and for the most of part have enjoyed them all

Posted

Trini Reyes as well. Never heard a good word. But am thoroughly them as a Sunday morning/afternoon cigar with a tea.

Guest robustog
Posted

HDM#1's which are a staple for me. :)

Posted

Punch cigars in general. I've never had a bad one, okay... I concede there are other more flavoursome cigars around, but I don't mind a Coronation for a quick smoke now and then.

Posted

Trini Reyes as well. Never heard a good word.

Really? Until recent years the Reyes (and Trinidad in a whole) was the most prized très petit corona on every cigar board…

  • Like 1
Posted

I though my ADD was bad.

I have never had a great Cuaba. Yup, that includes the entire line.

Posted

I though my ADD was bad.

I have never had a great Cuaba. Yup, that includes the entire line.

I have had some really nice Cuaba's. The devinos and exclusivos more specifically. A very woodsy change of pace cigar that needs quite a bit of time. Takes a bit of getting used to but once you do quite nice IMO.

  • Like 1
Posted

Cuaba Divinos hole.gif

...and Salomones for that matter, Not smoked many of the other Cuaba's but very rarely do I get a 'bad one' of these two.

Posted

SLR A and Regios do not get enough love. The brand itself is now devoid of the pc, corona, lonsdale, and Churchill. I always like all of them.

One cigar I do not care for is the BBF. Smoked many old, recent, and kind-of- old ones, and they never do anything for me. Tastes like paper.

But I do like bolivar as a marque.

  • Like 1
Posted

Really? Until recent years the Reyes (and Trinidad in a whole) was the most prized très petit corona on every cigar board…

Really.

I've only been smoking cigars over the last few years and have only ever really been on this forum (as well as one other highly inactive forum). Since I started with cigars, I generally haven't heard much good about the Reyes.

Posted

RA Extra. We love these. Please forward unwanted boxes to Canadianbeaver. She will dispose of them properly for you!

  • Like 3

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

Community Software by Invision Power Services, Inc.