Top 5 NC's you would have in your rotation.

[seanbeer]

I have had a few NCs and it has came to a point for me, cuban or quit smoking..

[godpheonix]

For NC's nothing beats a padron, of course thats also the case with the pricetag on them LOL

Padron 1926 80th anniversary

Padron 1926 No 9

Coronado by la Flor Double corona

Illusione Epernay Le taureau

Arturo Fuente Don Carlos No 2

[mikek]

This is easy for me I have about A half dozen I smoke regularly.

1 Padron 1926 Maduro Torpedo

2 Oliva V,belicoso,or lancero

3 Padron 1964 maduro,robusto

4 Tatuaje Havana VI torpedo

5 Punch rothchild oscuro

6 Oliva Master Blends III torpedo,robusto

7 Ashton VSG any size but more robustos

Those cigars I am never out of they have been my go to non Cuban smokes for sometime! I also keep some Camacho Triple Maduro torpedo althogh they are not the knee knocker they were when they first hit the market!

[anacostiakat]

Hmmmm. The number uno is probably the Davidoff 2000 Vintage Panatella Extras! Outstanding cigar.

The older Fuente WOAM (Work of Art Maduro) are great IMHO.

I like the Padron 64's too but find them to work better for me as an after dinner smoke.

The La Flor Dominicana Cabinet Selection Cameroon was another winner.

Havent had any of these in a bit. Although I do have some of the Davidoff's. Might have to dig one out. . .

[Mr.T]

I like the Ashton VSGs, La Aurora and Illusione Epernays. I too really like the original Puros Indios by Reyes, but I am not a fan of the newer ones....

[BehikeLover2]

1. Nothing bigger than a Robusto Format. The perfect size to keep my attention, everything bigger than that is just too much.

I like the Drew Estate Liga Privada No.9 its unbelievable how much smoke this thing produces. You might see it smoking in some streetriots.

[Aksan]

1. -----------

2.-------------

3.--------------

4.----------------

5.------------------

I just don' t bother anymore.

[Wil]

Into the last third of an Illusione Rothchildes. My first one of these. It has a bit of everything - sweetness, spice, leather. Not bad at all!

[mikek]

This is easy for me I have about A half dozen I smoke regularly.

1 Padron 1926 Maduro Torpedo

2 Oliva V,belicoso,or lancero

3 Padron 1964 maduro,robusto

4 Tatuaje Havana VI torpedo

5 Punch rothchild oscuro

6 Oliva Master Blends III torpedo,robusto

7 Ashton VSG any size but more robustos

Those cigars I am never out of they have been my go to non Cuban smokes for sometime! I also keep some Camacho Triple Maduro torpedo althogh they are not the knee knocker they were when they first hit the market!

After over thirty years of smokeing cigars I have come to the conclusion A GOOD cigar is where you find it !

[fokker4me]

1- AF Opus X Petit Lancero

2- AF Anejo Shark

3- AF Casa Fuente Corona Gorda

4- Davidoff Puro D'Oro Sublime

5- Tatuaje El Triunfador brown label Lancero

[GernBlansten]

In order:

1. AF Anejo 46

2. Illusione Epernay - any

3. WOAM

4. DCL

5. Casa Fuente CG

[rtrimbath]

#1. Padron 1926 No. 9

#2. Oliva V Torpedo

#3. Arturo Fuente Anejo Shark

#4. AB Prensado Robusto

#5. Herrera Esteli Piramide Fino

[BBS]

As others have mentioned;

Padron 1964 - Principe and Exclusivo

- I enjoy both the maduro and regular wrapper. In fact, a '64 with the regular wrapper is still on the list of the best sticks I've ever had.

Padron Family Reserve 45th

- Darn expensive, but every one I've ever had delivers. Wonderful stuff.

Tatuaje - TAA2011 - present

- The Tatuaje TAA's really pull out the stops, are a very good smoke....very good.

Tatuaje - Petite Cazadore Reserva

- Absolute little spice bomb smokes. Fantastic AM with coffee stick.

[bigbwalls]

Liga Privada Dirty Rat / T52

Padron 1926 Maduro No. 35

Headley Grange / JD Howard Reserve / Las Calaveras

La Palina Kill Bill 2

La Flor Dominicana Double Ligero Maduro

[Laxman]

Probably would be none but if I had to padron 40th anni or 80th. Had a few opus back in the day but can't remember the names that were nicotine bombs. Had a couple of grey cliffs that were decent. Couple davidoffs but that's about it.

[TheLiquidGator]

Any Oliva O with a cloth band. Killer smoke.

My Father #1 and #4

Ilusione Roth

Anjeo 46

Original brown label El Triunfador Lancero

Opus A size

[dtrott]

1)Padron 1926 2)Ashton Heritage 3)Casa Magna Dominus 4)Headley Grange/Four Sticks 5)Tatuaje Brown

[TM-US]

Casa Fuente Corona Gorda

Fuente anejo shark

Fuente Opus X petit lancero

Davidoff white label 2012

My Father lancero

Not too much else, I'd smoke, but I would put a couple others as close:

Davidoff Puro D'Oro sublime

Davidoff Millennium blend lancero / lonsdale

Tatuaje El Triunfador lancero

Pardon 85th anniversary

[TM-US]

Casa Fuente Corona Gorda

Fuente anejo shark

Fuente Opus X petit lancero

Davidoff white label 2012

My Father lancero

Not too much else, I'd smoke, but I would put a couple others as close:

Davidoff Puro D'Oro sublime

Davidoff Millennium blend lancero / lonsdale

Tatuaje El Triunfador lancero

Pardon 85th anniversary

[MIKA27]

For me here are the following faves;

1: Padron Anniversario 1964 Torpedo

2: Padron Maduro 3000 (Brilliant cigar and highly underrated IMO)

3: Camacho Room 101 - 305 Robusto and 702 Toro

4: Drew Estate Liga Privada T52 Toro

5: Paul Stulac - No Dress Code Torpedo

[dan5974]

Any 5 Gurkhas

It's hard to name just 5,but here goes.

1.Anejo 46

2.Oliva Melanio Petit Corona

3.DPG Blue Demitasse

4.My Father #4

5.Diesel Corona

My favorite NCs are no longer produced,The Pepin made Padilla Miami,and the La Aurora Cien Anos.

[airtrade]

- Rocky Patel Edge Maduro Torpedo

- AF Anejo

- Ashton VSG

- Perdomo Lot 23

- Partagas Black Label

[airtrade]

Whoops double post

[kuzi16]

Davidoff 2000

Avo XO

Elogio Serie Habano

Room 101 Connecticut.

Avo Domaine no. 50

[TheDistrictJP]

El Triunfador #6 only and non-original.

Cain Daytona #4 only.

Tatuaje Cabinet Noellas only.

The occasional Undercrown.