What cigar in your collection would you trade right now?

[El Presidente]

What cigar in your collection would you trade right now?

You simply don't like it. Heaven knows your poison might be someone else's Perignon......what would you trade right now

[Maplepie]

RyJ Reservas. Cohiba Gran Reservas.

Honestly, these things underpreformed for me. Being that Cohiba is one of my top 3 marcas and RyJ Churchills are a staple in my humidor, i went pretty deep into these two.

Edit: Note i cannot trade at this moment. It's also a complex scenario with them. PMs are welcomed on how they're smoking though

The trade value is absolutely ridiculous and wouldn't mind giving them up for a lot of things that are alright. Same with the ERDM Balthasars as apparently, those are valued ridiculously now too... No vikingos though.

[bugman78629]

I THINK I HAVE OCD.........FIND IT HARD TO LET GO OF MY CIGARS

[Rye]

Empty your PM bin! ^^^ It's gonna get busy with a post like that.

[CdnLimitada]

Looking forward to seeing some of these answers

My 2012 plpcs have taken a bit of a nose dive in the past few months but I'm sure they will come around as they are super young still. Other than that, I am still new to this so curious to see how some that are not fantastic right now will turn out in time. I wouldn't give up on them yet

[Rye]

Inmensos were that way for me, but I fixed it.

Love LGC, but those big fat versions just didn't do it for me

[Maplepie]

Empty your PM bin! ^^^ It's gonna get busy with a post like that.

quiet Ry, you got your Cohiba GR already

[dangolf18]

Nothing right now...perhaps my remaining NCs.

[PapaDisco]

Sadly, I'm not overstocked enough to trade hardly anything. And much of what I have is still so new that even if I haven't liked it at first I'm still planning on hanging on to it for a few more years and see what happens.

Boli RC's continue to *****-slap me, so I probably ought to kick them to the curb. I'd swap my dark and swarthy Punch Punch 2010's for some of those light, honey-dipped 2009's from code ROL. Probably everything else is worth keeping for a while longer.

[Stanislaw]

All my Trinidad's, I've just had no luck with the robustos or the Reyes but I continue to trust the aging process and they are jammed into the back for now....

[LP9]

@dangolf18 already said what I was thinking when reading through here. Any of my NC's !

[finecigar]

I am with bugman.. For the most part I have a very hard time to see any cigars go unless I'm smoking... Maybe a hoarding problem... I do have a partial box of ERdM CS and SCdlH La punta that I'm not super fond of but I'll probably just end up keeping to see if years help them

[next]

My PL Encantos..... 6 units smoked and nothing good...

[anjimj]

I would trade in my Monte 2's that I bought blind for some PSP Monte 2's from Rob!

[scottm12]

I still have 3 fake r&j belicosos gifted from a friend from 4 years ago, the bands are so bad I should upload a photo to the "fohiba" page

[Skyfall]

PLPC and Cohiba Secretos. Hands down! Turds for the taking.

[Bclass1]

I still have 3 fake r&j belicosos gifted from a friend from 4 years ago, the bands are so bad I should upload a photo to the "fohiba" page

Lol, keep those around for reference...

[Lotusguy]

That box of Vegueros Especiales #1 - what was I thinking?

Ah yes - they were cheap.

[fingerburner]

Sancho Panza Sanchos for me. My '05's are bland and a total waste of 2+ hours.

[hebbe72]

First of all, I am a cigarsmoker, not a collector. Hence I do not have a collection simply a stash. I am also aware of the fact that there are lots of people out there with a bigger stash than mine.

I only buy what I am confident I will enjoy, so not very much for trade.

However, in a weak moment I bought a box of Los statos deluxe in the faint hope that it would be a cheap yard stick. Cheap it was, but it barely makes it as a yard stick...

[Reevzy]

I've got one Monte 2 left out of a box of 10 that just never worked. I'm yet to smoke a good Monte 2 and this last remaining one in my humidor is the constant lingering bad name for them which is a shame. Still haven't brought myself to buying anymore because of it

[ramon_cojones]

nothing, each purchase is sampled and thought out so I'm content with my collection

[McNasty]

H Upmann Mag 48 EL. I will smoke them but never really found these to be worth the time invested in smoking them.

To make matters worse the box that I had ordered had been delayed in the mail for some months, second one was delivered and they both arrived at the same time. By that time I was already in Afghanistan and rather than have my wife return one I just paid for them both. I probably have about 30 left.

[westg]

La Flor De Cano Grandiosos completely under filled sponges, actually I would not even give them away let alone trade them.

[ned]

i dont have anything near what most members have but if i had something that someone really wanted i would probably be willing to trade it