You pick the Strength  

355 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Posted

Sharing cigars with a host of people I am often surprised how people's tastes and tolerances differ when it comes to cigars.

As an exercise, where would you put the strength of a D4? For the purpose of the exercise we are not talking about nicotine level "hit" but rather:

Weight on the palate + robustness of flavour.

have a crack at the poll and share any insights. Let's see if this pans out the way I think it will looking.gif

  • Replies 89
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Posts

What - no La Escepcion in your list? LOL.

Mild in terms of flavor intensity, or in terms of strength? It really should be clarified...

Posted

I've always found them to be straight up medium bodied. Very nuanced with layers of flavor but not what I'd consider to be a heavy smoke by any means

Posted

Majority of the cigars I've smoked in my short time would have to be the PDS4. I still can't break down all the different flavors I taste, however for me I say this is a medium full cigar.

Posted

This is one cigar I have NEVER tried! Would like to, but many say it is a very inconsistent too mass produced cigar.

Posted

The average PSD4 I would say is medium, but like any other bestseller (e.g. Monte #4) it suffers with its huge production.

I've already had strong and mild ones.

Posted

When they are on for me, medium full is where they are at. Cracker when on.

Posted

The PSD4 is one of my first box purchases. It's always been pretty full body to me, but since I've had fuller bodied cigars (like CoRo and RASS) I'll rank it medium to full

Posted

Probably one of the cc's I've smoked the most of with years from 05-12 and at best they are always med-full and at worst med but still have great flavor. However for me the cigar all comes together when it is med-full, I feel adding a little mongrel or robustness rounds out the whole palatte and flavor profile of this cigar where as when they're med in body they lack a little something.

Posted

med to full

Posted

where would you put the strength of a D4? For the purpose of the exercise we are not talking about nicotine level "hit" but rather:

Weight on the palate + robustness of flavour.

I believe that a cigar can be full flavored, but not full in strength; the attributes are mutually exclusive. As for intensity, I'd say when D4's are not sour, they are very full/rich in its flavors.
Posted

bang on medium for me, I consider something like a Bolivar RC as full bodied

Posted

One of the first Cuban cigars I smoked, it always had a rich, full flavor that I still love.

I voted med-full and stand by that.

Same here. The PSD4 was the first cc I smoked and I fell in love.

Posted

I would say medium, but I was looking for 'Awesome' as a choice, as the 2 boxes I've gone through (both 2012) have been that!

I love the spicyness and I find for me, they go exceedingly well alongside a glass of red.

Posted

Medium to full for me as well

Always good they never disappoint

Posted

This is the first box i bought and for flavours i would rank it full.

To me it rarely misses the mark. I'm on my 3rd box and being relatively new to the game (ie smoking cigars for about 2 years) that would make it the one i like to go to. My current box is an aged 2008 box that is smoking extremely well so its lasting longer then the first 2.

Posted

medium when fresh, med full with 5 years on them in your face full flavor blowing up your nostrils on the retrohale, love it when there's a lot going on like 6 year old d4s

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

Community Software by Invision Power Services, Inc.