534 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 186
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Posts

Love that the wrapper shade didn't scare you off....  I don't get folks eschewing anything other than a dark wrapper.   "I don't want that. It's not dark enough".   Man, I've had some incredible smoke

Dip 2 all day long..

For me it is the Hoyo LE 2011... not on the list, sorry.

Posted

I am not so much of a Piramides guy but my first Cohiba Piramides Extra I tried yesterday just blew me away. People were looking at me to figure out why I was grinning so much lol3.gif

Posted

Matthew and I just smoked a pair of Monte 2's... Can't believe it but they were terrific. They were singles but I am sure they had some real age on them. Who'd a figured?

Posted

Just picked up another single Cohiba Piramides extra - will smoke it shortly and if it is anything like the last one, I will definitely cave and get that box, even though they are quite pricey.

Posted

Just finished up a VR Unico MGA SEP 10, outstanding cigar tonight!

Posted

Have boxes of Piramides in stock in my humidor from various years and brands and the Up #2 is blowing everything out of the water right now....I believe a 2010 box. Wow! If this this is H. Upmann profile I want in! Unfortunately all my other H.Upmann experiences from the mags, to the Sir Winnie, Connie's etc have been underwelming. Monte #2 is a close second and smoking terrific as well.

JD

Posted

I think this is really a hard question, I voted Upmann but I would have voted Monte 2 if I could have voted twice. I am a big fan of both marca's, although I have only smoked fairly recent stock of both and my Monte's where very "on". I have never tried the CPE or the Dip's though, so there might be somewhat of a bias. Anyway two of my favorite smokes.

  • 1 year later...
Posted

CPE has really come in to it's own. Outstanding cigar. Wasn't sure it could stand between the sig vi and behikes but it certainly does.

  • Like 1
Posted

CPE has really come in to it's own. Outstanding cigar. Wasn't sure it could stand between the sig vi and behikes but it certainly does.

Agree. Had one earlier this month and it was stellar.

Posted

I voted PSP2 when this first came around.

Not feeling so a year and a half later. Vote goes to CPE now, followed by HU #2

By the way, is it tomorrow yet? Still looking for Rob's take on this smartass.gif

Posted

Monty 2 are good, GR superb!

Cohiba PE ...I like a lot

HUPP 2

VR flavour profile...not so much

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Posted

Have smoked all but VR Unicos and Cohiba.

My favourite PSP2 especially the tubos

Monte 2 also very good.

Dip 2 not so much.

Posted

I need to give it to the PSP2......have had a lot of great ones over the last couple years.......followed by the Monte 2 for me.

Totally agree.

Posted

I voted PSP2. When they are going right, they are outstanding. There's also something about the layered texture of the smoke from those PSP2s that I love.

2. Monte 2

3. Cohiba Piramides

Note: Haven't tried the VR unicos yet.

Posted

Upmann 2 for me has been the most consistent. Monte 2 when they are on target are hard to beat but too inconsistent for me.

P2 is the dark horse I forget about. Have not smoke one I have not liked yet.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

Community Software by Invision Power Services, Inc.