Recommended Posts

  • Replies 54
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted

I dont have 4 boxes of anything as I'm still in "build up" mode. I am however working toward stocking up on:

San Cristobal Mercaderes (2 boxes)

San Cristobal El Principe (3 boxes)

Juan Lopez #2 (3 boxes)

Boli GM (2 boxes)

Cohiba Siglo VI (2 boxes)

Posted

My definition of stocked up would be at least 4 boxes.

not really my definition of "stocked up"...probably missed a few...4 boxes or more...

partagas...tres petit coronas

diplomaticos...dip#4

bolivar...coronas

hoyo de monterrey...du depute

ryj...cazadores

montecristo...monty#5

ramon allones...mille fleurs

punch...royal selection#12

ramon allones...belvederes

por larranaga...petit coronas

cohiba...sigloII

bolivar...petit coronas

bolivar...coronas juniors

partagas...serie du connaisseur #2

partagas...shorts

upmann...petit coronas

ramon allones...small club coronas

bolivar...gold medal

san cristobal de la habana...el principe

bolivar...especiales no2

ramon allones...celestiale finos

upmann...noellas

upmann…half coronas

derrek

Posted

Bolivar CE, CG, CJ & PC

Cohiba CEs

Montecristo #1,#2 & #4

Partagas Lonsdales

RyJ Cazadores & EX#3

SLR DCs

VR Unicos

Posted

I just got split box montes 2 and a boc edmundo , a cpl of Plpc and slr regios and a box of coro. Thinking of buying box of rass for more long term aging.

Posted

I have said it before and will again, ignoring the expectations of what a Hoyo should taste like, the Hoyo EL was the best of teh 3 last year.

Let's agree to disagree. Tried the hoyo multiple times now from different boxes as well as 1966s and the 1966 s beat them hands down IMHO. Different folks, different strokes.

Posted

not really my definition of "stocked up"...probably missed a few...

partagas...tres petit coronas

diplomaticos...dip#4

bolivar...coronas

hoyo de monterrey...du depute

ryj...cazadores

montecristo...monty#5

ramon allones...mille fleurs

punch...royal selection#12

ramon allones...belvederes

por larranaga...petit coronas

cohiba...sigloII

bolivar...petit coronas

bolivar...coronas juniors

partagas...serie du connaisseur #2

partagas...shorts

upmann...petit coronas

ramon allones...small club coronas

bolivar...gold medal

san cristobal de la habana...el principe

bolivar...especiales no2

ramon allones...celestiale finos

upmann...noellas

upmann…half coronas

derrek

Amazing selection Derrek.

Posted

Wow. These are some impressive collections. I'm lucky to have a box of anything let alone 4 or 5 boxes. Maybe someday after I'm rich.

Posted

Agreed. But….I absolutely LOVE the RyJ Dukes. can't find any anymore…..for example. And thats a fairly recent limited production stick.

We can't be friends any more LOL!!

Have not had any ER that has made me say I need to stock up on these and ELs well those are terrible (sup piggy).

Posted

Boxes that I haven't opened yet mmmmm..,
This is what I like to smoke; after I read this thread I just opened Diplomaticos NO.5 from Jan 02... Damn you FOH.
PUNCH super robustos Asia regional 2007 cabinet 50 (4 boxes)
PUNCH serie d’Oro No.1 UK regional 2008 (2 boxes)
ROMEO Y JULIETA short Churchills jar (2 jars)

 PUNCH double coronas cabinet of 50 from 2005 (6 boxes)
 ROMEO Y JULIETA Churchills 1994-1995-1997-2001(15 boxes) (1 box)
 PARTAGAS serie D especial edicion limitada 2010 (3 boxes)
MONTECRISTO double coronas EL 2001 (3 boxes 2 boxes)

 MONTECRISTO No.1 2001-2003-2008 (2 boxes each)
MONTECRISTO No.2 Gran reserva cosecha 2005(3 boxes 2 boxes)
DIPLOMATICOS No.5 (6 boxes 5 boxes)
VEGUEROS especiales No.2 1999-2000 (7 boxes)
Basically this is all my stash and the rest is all in singles or opened boxe.

update:12-16-2014

Posted

Boxes that I haven't opened yet mmmmm..,

This is what I like to smoke; after I read this thread I just opened Diplomaticos NO.5 from Jan 02... Damn you FOH.

 PUNCH super robustos Asia regional 2007 cabinet 50 (4 boxes)

 PUNCH serie d’Oro No.1 UK regional 2008 (2 boxes)

 PUNCH double coronas cabinet of 50 from 2005 (6 boxes)

 ROMEO Y JULIETA short Churchills jar (2 jars)

 ROMEO Y JULIETA Churchills 1994-1995-1997-2001(17 boxes)

 PARTAGAS serie D especial edicion limitada 2010 (3 boxes)

 DIPLOMATICOS No.5 (6 boxes 5 boxes)

 MONTECRISTO No.1 2001-2003-2008 (11 boxes)

 MONTECRISTO No.2 Gran reserva cosecha 2005(3 boxes 2 boxes)

 MONTECRISTO double coronas EL 2001 (3 boxes 2 boxes)

 VEGUEROS especiales No.2 1999-2000 (7 boxes)

Basically this is all my stash and the rest is all in singles or opened boxes.

Wow

Posted

I have said it before and will again, ignoring the expectations of what a Hoyo should taste like, the Hoyo EL was the best of teh 3 last year.

I agree. Have had two boxs of 1966 and two boxs of RA extra both amazing . Right now however the EL Hoyos have been terrific and have prefered these over the other two.No one slap me please !!

Posted

I have said it before and will again, ignoring the expectations of what a Hoyo should taste like, the Hoyo EL was the best of teh 3 last year.

I have a few boxes and I'm hoping they turn into something special over time. I smoked a Epi no.2 and the short pyramid back to back and noticed very little difference. For the price difference I'd rather get a box of Epi no.2.

Posted

OK, so I have 4 boxes of Upmann Royal Robusto, and 4 boxes of RG Panetelas. Everything else 3 boxes or fewer.

BTW, I don't know what Shlomo and you go on about - I found the HDM Short Hoyo Piramides terrible and not worthy of the HDM name :confused:

Not even in the same universe as the RAE for me.

I guess that's where the personal taste come into play. Can't even sell the box of extras I have( have tried on classified site) but found the HDMs much better. Would rather have a regular production box at half the price than either though.

Posted

Definitely go with the Royal Robusto have only been able acquire one box here. Would not swap your four boxs of RG panetelas for a box of HDM Piramides though.

I would swap that. Don't you know Claus has the good stuff. I know some of those panatelas boxes have almost 10 years on them. Yummm

Posted

It all comes down to individual taste. You love HdM EL and some hate them, they love RACF and you don't get it. Thank god for variety :) I personally can't comment on the HdM EL because I haven't smoked one yet...

What I have found with the RACF is that the cigar has mellowed and rounded out significantly since it's release. It still has the nicotine kick, but it's not nausea inducing as Rob and Smithy experienced when first smoked. I reviewed is several months ago here: http://www.friendsofhabanos.com/forum/index.php?showtopic=110013

Posted

I'm a bit surprised at the RACF love too. Not even close to enjoyable for me. RASS or RAAS beats it 9 out of 10 times for me.

And Art, if the HdM Short Hoyo had a Cohiba band, we all know you'd be slurping at the limited teat. :rolleyes:

If it had a cohiba band, it would be a different blend......

Posted

Of course its individual taste. Good thing too. I haven't had a RACF in over a year, so maybe I'll give one another shot soon. Its just that these have been so widely available so as not to even be "limited" that I wonder how Cuba was able to roll so many boxes of a difficult size like that without causing big problems with quality. Maybe I just smoked young ones, or poorly constructed ones. Either way, the half dozen or so I have enjoyed have just been gobs of smoke (or lack thereof) and nothing else for me. Like I said though, I'll give 'em another shot soon.

There were 4,000 boxes produced and I think the reason why they are still easy to get is that they were reviewed by Rob and others and found to be too strong to smoke. They have evolved beautifully and are really a very different cigar than they were 12-18 months ago. You also can't beat the shape -- how many EL/RE are that shape? The new UK RE, but that's it. Retaste and let me know what you think.

Posted

Monte GE (8 and a partial)

BRC(4)

RACF (2 and 22/25)

BRC, huh? Curious about your reasons for stocking up on them. Are they a/t or the regular dress boxes? I've been toying with the idea of picking up a dress box. Any date codes that have been good for you?

Thanks!

Posted

Ive got 4 boxes of HdM short piramides an I have found them to be great I smoked some RACF recently and I probably going to buy a box of those soon

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

Community Software by Invision Power Services, Inc.